Many articles have been written on teaching progressions
and mechanics of throwing technique. This article,
however, deals with some of the pitfalls coaches often
encounter while trying to implement these progressions in
practice.
For example, here are some questions that I've been asked
many times at clinics or in discussions with other coaches
at meets:
* How do you know when it's the right time to move on to a
more complicated exercise?
* What's the right number of throws to perform in a given
practice?
* Is it better to practice one event per day or multiple events?
The general answer to all of these is invariably "it depends
on the individual," but I'd like to discuss some general
outlines that could be applicable to most teaching
scenarios that the coach could encounter.
1. Establish the basics.
Throwing is a sport of repetition. It's critical from the first day
that the proper teaching mechanics are established.
Getting it right the first time is important because, once a
bad habit has been established, it usually takes about three
times the number of repetitions to modify it.
Both coach and athlete should resist the temptation to
advance through the learning process too quickly in an effort
to get more distance at a faster rate.
Shortcuts can hinder the long-term development of a
thrower by taking these types of short cuts. Fulfilling an
athlete's true throwing potential is a long, gradual process
that shouldn't be rushed.
Advancement through more complicated progressions
should happen only when an athlete has mastered the
basic techniques.
2. Know when to pull out the measuring tape.
Throwers are judged by how far they throw. So it's only
natural that they're going to want to know how far they're
throwing. This type of feedback is important because it
really lets them know if they're improving.
However, it should not be the only focus of a training
session. Charting the improvement of a young thrower
should be a balance of developing consistency in execution
and producing better distances through technical
improvements. These two things don't necessarily go hand
in hand.
This is where the art of coaching comes into play - when a
coach must decide when to focus on the task at hand, or to
loosen the reins and let the thrower go for distance.
What coaches and athletes need to remember is that
establishing consistency of movement usually leads to
breakthroughs in distance. Learning usually occurs at
85-90% intensity when throwing, while throwing at 100% or
more all the time usually leads to erratic results.
I usually find that throwers who can reproduce a throwing
technique in practice 8 out of 10 times or better will usually
be able to reproduce the technique under the stress of
competition. This consistency usually occurs at
sub-maximal effort (85-95%). Of course, it's perfectly fine to
let the thrower see how far he or she can throw from time to
time to see the progress being made.
3. Go for quality over quantity.
How many throws should one take in practice?
More is not necessarily better.
Pay close attention to the quality of the throws in practice.
Once that quality starts to drop, it's usually a signal that it's
time to stop.
Throwers should never be put in a position where they have
to focus hard just to maintain basic technique due to fatigue.
Throwing is a performance sport, not an endurance contest.
All you need is one good throw in a competition, and
success is not measured by a series of throws, but by your
best throw in a series.
Building a base by making a large volume of throws to
"build a throwing base" doesn't make sense. There should
be a purpose to each throw.
I have found that 20-25 throws, at about 80-90% intensity,
is usually the maximum a beginning thrower can take in a
session and still maintain quality. If the throwing intensity is
lower, it may be more like 30-35 throws. When poor
execution occurs due to fatigue after only a short time, say
10-12 throws, stop the practice or switch to a different type
of throw or to a drill where the thrower can still execute with
a high level of success.
4. Work on one concept at a time.
When teaching beginners how to execute the throwing
events, it's important to make things as easy as possible.
This can be done by focusing on one technical element at a
time. Giving an athlete multiple cues usually leads to
confusion in the thrower's mind, because it's impossible to
concentrate on two things once.
A good throw usually feels effortless, and this feeling
cannot be achieved while trying to do many things at once.
Focusing on one technical element is enough.
When talking about teaching concepts, it should be noted
that there are two types of concepts - rhythmic and
technical. Rhythmic concepts have to do with speed of
execution and acceleration patterns within a given throw.
Technical concepts have to do with hitting a certain position
during the course of a throw.
A major mistake that's often made is to ask a thrower to
work on one rhythmic concept and one mechanical concept
at the same time. This is essentially asking the thrower to
work on two things at once, which can be hard to do.
The following is an example of how this comes about:
A coach has a thrower work on hitting a certain position
when he lands in the power position at the front of the ring.
After a few repetitions the coach then asks the thrower to try
to hit the same position while also speeding up the pivot in
the middle of the ring. Actively trying to do both of these
things can be hard to accomplish. A better way to frame the
task is to speed up the throw in the middle of the ring, but
not to ask that they hit a certain power position as well.
Instruct the thrower to focus on the speed in the middle of
the ring, and see if they still hit the power position as
desired without thinking about it. If they are able to do it,
then things are good. If not, then more work is needed on
hitting the power position as desired until it becomes
second nature.
5. Help each beginner find his or her "own" throw.
Throwers come in many shapes and sizes and have
various strengths and weaknesses. These need to be
taken into consideration when developing an individual's
technique. I find that throwers tend to gravitate toward their
strengths when developing their technique, and I think this
should be encouraged. For example, a thrower with strong
legs will naturally try to use them a little more than a thrower
who has a more developed upper body and weaker legs.
Aside from establishing the basics of throwing technique,
it's hard to say that there's a right or wrong way for an
individual to throw. What's most important in all cases is
trying to find the most efficient way for each person to throw.
Relying on a certain technical model to develop a young
thrower can be a
double-edged sword. While a model can provide a nice
template for a young thrower to emulate, it's important that
the model also be one that suits the thrower's traits. It
wouldn't make sense for a thrower who is 2 meters tall and
fairly skinny to model his technique after a thrower who is
short, powerful and thick.
One should also take care not to follow the model's
technique too closely if it appears that it stifles some of the
thrower own natural efficiency. It is not wise to pay "tribute" to
a great thrower by duplicating his or her technique to the last
detail, but the coach could use that throw as a guideline to
develop and then streamline the athlete's personal
technique.
6. Throwing more than one event in the same workout.
Many times I'm asked, "Is it better to throw one event a day
or work on multiple events on the same day?"
Much of the answer has to do with how much time for
throwing you have each day. The rest of the answer has to
do with (1) how long a thrower can throw before lack of
focus and fatigue set in and (2) if the thrower is good at
transitioning from one event to another.
If there's a short amount of time each day to throw, then I'd
recommend throwing one event a day and making sure it's
done correctly. You never want to get into a situation where
you're rushing from event to event. Quality is the most
important factor for every training session.
The other factor that would preclude a thrower from training
two events in one session would be if the thrower's motor
patterns are adversely affected by back-to-back sessions.
This is sometimes the case with training rotational shot
putters who also throw the discus. Since the events are
similar, but the timing a little different, it can be difficult to
establish the correct rhythm when throwing both so close
together. If this is the case, then sessions may need to be
separated by days or hours instead of minutes.
7. Keep things fun.
The most important thing when teaching beginners a skill is
to keep things fun. I try to make the throwing sessions that I
conduct the highlight of the day for my throwers. I want them
to "want to be there" when throwing. Learning seems to
occur at a faster rate when things are fun, and most
personal bests are thrown when the athlete is loose and
relaxed and not too stressed during competition. A poor
result is more likely to occur when a thrower is trying too
hard rather than not trying hard enough. This can be seen
when a thrower is "too ready" to throw far, more often than
not because the training leading up to a meet has been
exceptional. This situation inadvertently raises expectations,
which in turn can cause the athlete to put too much
pressure on him- or herself. Careful evaluation by the coach
can usually pick up on this, although the more experience
one has with an athlete the easier it is to detect.
Conclusion
Teaching the throws is both an art and a science. A lot has
been written about the science, while relatively little has
been written about the art. The science of the throws can be
learned while studying of articles and film, but the art of
teaching comes mostly from experience. It's hoped that this
article has provided a few insights into teaching the throws,
so that the reader can steer clear of some of the mistakes
I've made. As I stated before, throwing is a sport of
repetition, and the long, steady path usually leads to long
distances and better results.
Don Babbitt is the throws coach at the University of
Georgia.
Athletes he coaches include shot put world champions
Adam Nelson (2005) and Reesew Hoffa (2007), U.S. record
holder and eight-time U.S. champion in the men's javelin
Breaux Greer, and two-time NCAA women's hammer throw
champion Jenny Dahlgren, among others.